Stars: They leave offhandedly judgmental Instagram comments just like us!

Lindsay Lohan, no stranger to the internet's ocean of oft-searing public opinion, came across a photo of fellow former child star Ariana Grande this past weekend. It's a selfie Ariana snapped with Hairspray Live! costar Dove Cameron, in which the two appear to be in character dress (or, at the very least, gussied up for promotional photos). Ariana is rocking a thick cat-eye liner and pink eyeshadow, which seems to indeed be the look for her Hairspray character Penny Pingleton.

As gorgeous — if heavily painted — as the two women look, Lindsay decided, like so many of us in the reply sections have, that she'd weigh in with her assessment.

"Too much makeup," the Mean Girls actress declared.

As PEOPLE noted, Lindsay felt strongly enough to make the "too much makeup" comment a second time underneath a second selfie of Ariana's. That one's captioned "Penny Lou P," making it even clearer that her makeup is probably for the show.

Ariana's response? None, publicly at least — she was too busy performing "Side to Side" at the 2016 American Music Awards, and preparing for Hairspray Live!'s December 7 performance.

See screen caps of Lindsay Lohan's comments to Ariana Grande below.