Karmelo Anthony Found Guilty In Murder Of Texas Teen Austin Metcalf At High School Track Meet

A Texas jury has found Karmelo Anthony guilty of murder in the fatal stabbing of fellow high school student Austin Metcalf, bringing a verdict to one of the most closely watched criminal cases in the country.

The verdict was delivered Tuesday in McKinney, Texas, more than a year after the deadly confrontation at a district-wide track and field meet in Frisco, a suburb of Dallas. According to courtroom reports, emotions ran high as the verdict was read. Members of the Metcalf family reacted visibly, while Anthony's mother reportedly wept as jurors announced their decision.

Fatal Encounter At Track Meet

The case stems from an April 2, 2025 incident during a rainy track meet involving students from Frisco Centennial High School and Frisco Memorial High School.

Prosecutors argued that Anthony fatally stabbed 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during an argument under a team tent. Metcalf later died in the arms of his twin brother, according to testimony from his family.

The confrontation occurred after Anthony, a student at Centennial High School, was sitting under Memorial High School's tent. Witnesses testified that Metcalf and others approached Anthony and told him to leave the area. What happened next became the focus of the murder trial.

Defense Claimed Self-Defense

Anthony's legal team maintained throughout the trial that he acted in self-defense.

Defense attorney Mike Howard argued that students from different schools often gather and socialize at track meets and claimed Anthony had been invited to the tent. Howard told jurors that Anthony faced physical intimidation and had reason to fear that multiple students could become involved in the confrontation.

The defense contended prosecutors failed to prove Anthony committed murder and argued he was reacting to an escalating situation.

Get our free mobile app

Prosecutors Called Stabbing An Intentional Act

Prosecutors rejected the self-defense claim and argued the evidence showed Anthony was responsible for the deadly encounter.

Lead prosecutor Bill Wirskye pointed to witness testimony that Anthony warned Metcalf to "touch me and find out" before the stabbing. He argued the confrontation was primarily between the two students and that evidence, including video presented during the trial, did not support claims that Anthony was surrounded or under attack.

During closing arguments, Wirskye repeatedly described the incident as murder and told jurors Anthony's actions led directly to Metcalf's death. He also argued that while many described the case as a tragedy, Anthony ultimately faced the consequences of decisions he made that day.

Witnesses Offered Differing Accounts

Several witnesses, including friends and teammates of Metcalf, testified during the trial.

Many agreed that Metcalf pushed Anthony during the confrontation, though testimony differed on the force of the push. Some witnesses said the contact was minor, while others characterized it differently. Several witnesses ultimately placed responsibility for the deadly outcome on Anthony.

A school resource officer also testified that Anthony admitted to the stabbing after the incident and asked whether Metcalf would be okay. According to testimony, Anthony also stated that he had warned Metcalf not to touch him.

Because several key witnesses were minors, the judge ordered that their identities not be publicly released.

Case Drew National Attention

The case gained widespread attention across the country, not only because of the circumstances surrounding the stabbing but also because of public debate that followed.

Metcalf was remembered by family members as an honor student, football team MVP, and respected leader among his peers. His father previously described him as a student with a 4.0 GPA who was loved by classmates and teammates.

Anthony, who had been released on a $250,000 bond and placed on house arrest while awaiting trial, was allowed to graduate under an agreement involving advocates and the Frisco Independent School District.

The case also generated discussion online regarding race. Metcalf was white and Anthony is Black. Civil rights groups and outside activists weighed in during the proceedings, though attorneys representing the Metcalf family repeatedly downplayed race as a central issue in the case.

Sentencing Phase Still Ahead

With the guilty verdict now delivered, attention will turn to the sentencing phase of the case. Additional proceedings are expected as the court determines Anthony's punishment for the murder conviction.

This remains a developing story, and additional updates are expected as sentencing information becomes available.