Lindsay Clancy Mistrial Declared, Defense Given One Hour To Appeal

A Massachusetts judge declared a mistrial Friday morning in the nationally watched murder trial of Lindsay Clancy after jurors said for a third time that they could not reach a unanimous verdict.

UPDATE:

In a dramatic courtroom moment, the judge has granted the defense one hour to appeal.

ORIGINAL STORY:

Judge William Sullivan announced the decision after the jury returned for its seventh day of deliberations and sent another note saying it remained deadlocked. Jurors had spent nearly 40 hours deliberating following a trial that lasted several weeks.

Clancy was charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the January 2023 deaths of her children, 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan, at the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts.

The central question for jurors was not whether Clancy killed her children. Rather, they were asked to determine whether she was criminally responsible for the killings or whether mental illness left her legally not responsible for her actions.

Jury Reported Being Deadlocked Three Times

Signs that jurors were struggling to reach a decision emerged earlier this week.

The jury first reported an impasse Tuesday. A second deadlock followed Wednesday, prompting Sullivan to give jurors a special instruction encouraging them to reconsider their positions and continue working toward a unanimous decision.

The situation became even more contentious Thursday amid allegations from the defense that one juror was refusing to properly follow the court's instructions regarding reasonable doubt. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington unsuccessfully sought to have the juror removed.

When jurors again told the court Friday that they could not reach a unanimous decision, Sullivan declared a mistrial.

Defense Argued Clancy Suffered From Postpartum Psychosis

Clancy pleaded not guilty to the murder charges, with her defense arguing that she was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings.

Her attorneys argued that Clancy's mental health deteriorated in the months before the deaths despite repeated attempts to seek psychiatric treatment. They maintained that her illness, combined with problems surrounding her treatment and medications, left her psychotic.

The defense also pointed to expert testimony supporting its contention that Clancy was experiencing psychosis when her children were killed.

Postpartum psychosis is a rare and severe psychiatric condition that can cause hallucinations, delusions and a loss of connection with reality. It is considered a psychiatric emergency.

Prosecutors Said The Killings Were Deliberate

Prosecutors acknowledged that Clancy struggled with her mental health but argued she was not psychotic when she killed her children.

Instead, prosecutors alleged Clancy deliberately created an opportunity to be alone with the children by sending her then-husband, Patrick Clancy, out of the house to pick up dinner and medication.

They argued that her actions before, during and after the killings showed planning and an understanding of what she was doing. The defense strongly disputed that interpretation, making Clancy's mental state the defining issue of the trial.

Get our free mobile app

What Happens To Lindsay Clancy After The Mistrial?

A mistrial caused by a deadlocked jury is not the same as an acquittal.

Because jurors did not reach a verdict, prosecutors can potentially retry Clancy before a new jury. The prosecution will now have to determine how it intends to proceed with the case.

The trial attracted national attention and renewed a broader conversation about postpartum mental illness, maternal health care and how the criminal justice system handles cases involving severe psychiatric conditions.

This is a developing story and will be updated as additional information becomes available.

If you or someone you know is struggling or in emotional distress, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.